Custom Property Agency

Specialty Insurance Servicing

Specialty Insurance Servicing

Specialty Insurance ServicingSpecialty Insurance ServicingSpecialty Insurance Servicing

Custom tailored insurance plans 

for the building blocks of your future

Your Insurance Services

Property Investor

Property Investor

Property Investor


Our relationship with the property owner is built with strategy, designed with insurance and supported with exemplary service. 

  • 1-4 Family Homes
  • ​4+ Family Homes and Buildings
  • ​Other Property

Our goal is to discover your specific needs and custom tailor a cost-effective insurance package suited to protect your investment portfolio. 

Personal Policy

Property Investor

Property Investor

We have years of insurance experience helping clients prepare for the unknown. Ask us about:


  • Homeowners
  • Personal Auto and Motorcycle
  • Personal Umbrella 
  • Jewelry 
  • Watercraft 
  • Recreational Vehicle

We can access many different insurance products so you can get the right one for you.

Commercial Policy

Property Investor

Commercial Policy

Each business has different insurance needs. We are here to look at the big picture and help you navigate through each area of coverage.

  • General Liability
  • Property Insurance
  • Business Auto 
  • Workers Compensation
  • NY Disability
  • Bonds 
  • Professional Liability

 Call us today for a personalized business assessment and find out how we can help protect your hard-earned assets.

Meet the ceo

Karen M. Catalano

Karen  Catalano started her insurance career in 1998, in Personal lines sales, and then moved to underwriting review and eventually to fulltime Commercial Lines CSR. After working behind a desk, Karen’s, ambition with the experience and knowledge she had acquired was to return to sales and work with business owners to better help them understand and make wise decisions when purchasing insurance, by using techniques of Risk Management & Loss Prevention.

Contact Us

Schedule a Free Asessment

Custom Property Agency

29 California Drive, Williamsville, New York 14221, United States

(716) 783-8276


Monday - Friday: 8am - 4pm

Saturday: Closed

Sunday: Closed